Friday, October 2, 2015

Craftsmen, the Workforce, and Eli Whitney

      Eli Whitney- inventor, successful business man, and non-individualist. In other words, Whitney didn't care about the individual. Now, I don't know everything about Eli Whitney, but from what I've read, he sounds like a person who cared more about profit than about people (sounds like someone else I know). Here's why.
      In 1793, Eli Whitney invented the modern cotton gin. This invention skyrocketed the cotton production, and was a major boost the the beginnings of the Industrial Revolution. With the Industrial Revolution comes factories, and with the factories comes, you guessed it, factory workers. And what do workers do? They put together machines. Up to this point, you may be wondering, 'what does Eli Whitney have to do with all of this?' Let me explain.
      Eli Whitney suggested the use of interchangeable parts. In other words, all of the gears of all watches will fit the same, no matter what watch it comes from, or all of the parts of a firearm will all fit the same way, no matter what firearm it came from. This may sound like an ingenious idea, and for some people, it was, but think about what it does to the craftsman. If all watches are made the same way, then the watch maker no longer makes watches unique to themselves.
      And guess who's used to work in the factories and put together these interchangeable parts? A “workforce of easily trained, semi-skilled men recruited from the waves of immigrants”1. The idea was that these “easily trained, semi-skilled men” would be able to buy a farm by saving up the money they earned in the factories. The problem with that is the “easily trained, semi-skilled part”. An “easily trained, semi-skilled” man can't run a farm, they wouldn't know how! They wouldn't have the creativity and knowledge required for running a farm. But what about the immigrants who used to live on farms? Wouldn't they be able to start a farm after wards and still be okay? Yes, they probably would, but what if they don't want to be a farmer? What if they came over to learn how to be a watch maker? Well, then they'll have a hard time finding someone to teach them. And because of interchangeable parts, they might as well stay in the factory, because the watches are all the same anyway.
So what does this have to do with Eli Whitney? Because it was all his idea. Or, at least, a large portion of it was. And where did he get this idea from? Well, he “realized” that “America [needed] to overcome Britain in manufactures”2, and in order to do that, America needed to “bypass the craftsman with a workforce”. Let me pause for a moment to give you the definition of “craftsman” and “workforce”. Craftsman [krafts-muhn, krahfts-]:1. a person who practices or is highly skilled in a craft; artisan.; 2. an artist. Workforce: 1. the total number of workers in a specific undertaking.; 2. the total number of persons employed or employable. The first one (craftsman) celebrates the individual. The second one (the work force), does not. According my reading, Eli Whitney would rather have a work force than craftsman, all because America “needed” to manufacture more than Britain. If you think about it, it's similar to our day. How? Let's take a look.
      In today's education, there's a huge emphasis on math and CTE (career and technology training). Kids today are being taught like Whitney's factory workers. They're meant to be “easily trained” and “semi-skilled”- on a higher level. Semi-skilled lawyers, semi-skilled programmers, semi-skilled doctors. The idea is that after a few years of school, they'll be able to go out and do whatever they want. But how are they supposed to do that if they don't know how? What are they going to do when they don't have to put together “interchangeable parts” anymore? How can they be creative in their profession, or life in general, if they've been taught to be “easily trained”, and “semi skilled”?
      We often think of this as a modern way of thinking, but, as we can see with Eli Whitney, this kind of philosophy was around a long time ago.