Thursday, October 22, 2015

The Poor's Bane: Social Welfare Programs
By Jade Simmons

      “Social welfare programs help those in need.” A misleading statement. Social welfare programs not only promote poverty, they encourage reliance on the government, and legal plunder. Too many times, our first reaction is to run to the government when we need help, and the money we get from the government is legally stolen money. Money taken from the “haves”, and given to the (often) undeserving “have-nots”. Despite that, we say that social welfare programs help us, but is that really true?
      I'm not saying that all people who use social welfare programs are evil, a lot of them are just lazy. And they're only lazy because they don't know how to work and care for themselves and their families. They depend on the government to do the work for them. When people find that they've spent all their money, their first reaction is to turn to the government. Social welfare programs have become a crutch that a lot of people can't, and don't want to get rid of. Ezra Taft Benson once said, “Unfortunately, there has been fostered in the minds of some an expectation that when we experience hard times, when we have been unwise and extravagant with our resources and have lived beyond our means, we should look to either the Church or government to bail us out. Forgotten by some of our members is an underlying principle of the Church welfare plan that 'no true Latter-day Saint will, while physically able, voluntarily shift from himself the burden of his own support'1.”2 We need to be able to pull our own weight. Obviously, there are times when we need will support, someone to lean on, but we shouldn't lean on them until we've done everything we can. When we fall into a rut, we can't wait for someone to pull us out, we have to start climbing out ourselves.
      Social welfare programs promote poverty. How? Well, think about it. You aren't required to work to get social welfare benefits. You just have to show up to collect your food stamps, and that's it. Why go looking for a good-paying job when you can just get money from the government? A recent study from Georgia State University found that “...the tax-benefit system creates poverty traps, rather than promoting behaviors that enable families to escape poverty.”3 Along with that, Robert Rector, a senior research fellow at the De Vos Center for Religion and Civil Society, found that “the Obama Administration is now illegally claiming authority to waive the TANF (Temporary Assistance for Needy Families) work requirements through a legal device called the section 1115 waiver authority under the Social Security law (42 U.S.C. 1315).”4 In other words, you don't need to work to receive benefits. This why people stay poor. They don't have to work for money, they just get it. And when people get “free” money, they usually don't appreciate it as much, and so they spend it. And if they're constantly spending their money, then they tend to run out of it, and when they run out of it, guess what they find? They're still poor! The social welfare programs didn't help them get out of their poverty, they just kept them in it.
      Legal plunder. Two words you wouldn't normally see together. Yet this is what the government does to put money in their social welfare programs. In his book The Law, Frederic Bastiat states: “You say: 'There are persons who have no money,' and you turn to the law. But the law is not a breast that fills itself with milk. Nor are the lacteal veins of the law supplied with milk from a source outside the society. Nothing can enter the public treasury for the benefit of one citizen or one class unless other citizens have been forced to send it in.” He goes on to say, “With this in mind, examine the protective tariffs, subsidies, guaranteed profits, progressive taxation, free credit, and public works. You will find that they are always based on legal plunder, organized injustice.”5 We pay for people to be lazy. Social welfare programs take money from those who work and give it to those who aren't required to. You could argue that the government is being “Robin Hood”, stealing from the rich and giving to the poor, but you also have to think about the hard working “poor” whom the government is stealing from as well. The social welfare programs, then, take from the working poor and give to the lazy poor.
      So what do the government's social welfare programs do? Not what they're supposed to do. Instead, of helping the needy, they create a society who is constantly looking for handouts, and constantly being plundered by the government. We are taught to be self-reliant. But how can we be if we're constantly leaning on the social welfare programs? How is it fair to take from those who work hard, and give to those who don't? Next time you find yourself going through hard times, stop and think before turning to the government for help.
Sources:
1Marion G. Romney, in Conference Report, Oct. 1973, p. 106

2October 1980 General Conference: “Prepare for Days of Tribulation”: Ezra Taft Benson



5Frederic Bastait: The Law: The Law and Charity; pg. 32